Environmental Impact of Low Emission Shipping: Measurements and Modelling Strategies
EnviSuM
 
PROGRAMME 2014-2020
priority
3 Transport
objective
3.4 Clean shipping

EnviSuM

The Interreg project EnviSuM provided policy makers and ship owners with sound evidence that strict, global environmental regulations of shipping can benefit human health and the environment without threatening business – the Baltic Sea served as the globally unique test case.
The challenge

Stricter environmental limits on sulphur emissions of ships made

Baltic Sea a global test case A new regulation to limit sulphur emissions from ships by the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) entered into force in 2015. The purpose of the so-called SECA regulation (Sulphur Emission Control Area) is to reduce the air pollution and thus the negative effects of shipping exhausts on human health and on the environment. Since then, all ships sailing the Baltic Sea need to comply with stricter limits than elsewhere, and in 2020 these stricter sulphur limits are implemented worldwide. This situation turned the Baltic Sea into a test region for environmental limits covering larger areas of several countries.

Decision makers in policy and shipping industry need solid information

Before SECA was implemented, there were heavy debates in the maritime sector about the costs for ship-owners to comply with the regulation. Ship-owners bear these costs, no matter how they reduce the sulphur emissions – be it by cleaning the exhaust gas or by using higher quality fuels. These costs are transferred to their customers and ultimately to the consumers. This discussion showed that there is a need for up-to-date science-based information to guide future legislation on shipping emissions – among decision makers in both policy and business. Against this background, the Interreg project EnviSuM developed and applied state-of the-art measurement methods and models.

Budgets

EnviSuM
in numbers
  • 3.22
    Million
    Total
  • 2.22
    Million
    Erdf
  • 0.00
    Million
    Eni + Russia
  • 0.17
    Million
    Norway

Achievements

Sound measuring and modelling shows: environmental regulation works

Several research institutions with support of businesses and public administration from altogether seven countries took stock of the effects of SECA on human health, environment and the economy, namely the shipping sector. To this end, they used local and pan-Baltic measurements of the air composition and combined them with different models. These studies found that 1) negative economic effects of SECA concerning the rise of fuel costs and modal shift from sea to land did not occur as it was predicted; 2) the health, environmental and economic benefits of SECA outweigh the costs; 3) tight environmental regulation can encourage innovation: the reduction in emissions can create business benefits to the maritime cluster. All in all, the test case of stricter environmental limits for ships run in the Baltic Sea between 2015 and 2020 provided sound scientific evidence that the regulation works well without heavily impairing business. The results of the EnviSum project can serve decision makers in policy and business all across the globe as all coastal countries are facing the sulphur cap in 2020 and possibly new environmental regulation in the future.

Three large port cities get precise model studies on ship-borne air pollution

Next to the overall results of the model studies, the project partners carried out local studies on air pollution from ships, namely in Gothenburg (Sweden), the Tri-City (Poland) and St. Petersburg (Russia). In Poland, it was the first time that effects on shipping emissions on a local scale were inventorised and modelled. In Sweden, the local study showed that the sulphur emissions from ships decreased by 70 % within only one year, the year that the SECA regulation entered into force.

Decision support for the shipping industry

The project also addressed the shipping industry's compliance with the SECA regulation. The partners examined how efficient the different techniques for removing pollution from exhaust gases are. An online tool was set up that can help ship-owners assess the costs and benefits of the different techniques for their fleet. A study found that in general, ship-owners operating in the Baltic Sea region comply well with the SECA regulation, but compliance needs to be monitored regularly and noncompliance needs to be sanctioned in order to make the regulation effective. However, there were many challenges concerning the usability of engines and technical devices. Wide-spread air pollution control devices will not be able to match future obligations of the global marine pollution convention and need to be technically improved or replaced by better solutions.

EUR 2.22 million of support from the European Union helped policy, science and industry from across the macro-region to demonstrate how the Baltic Sea region pioneers clean shipping - in a global perspective.The results will be further used within the Clean Shipping Project Platform.

Outputs

Final report: CleanShipping - Exploring the impact of emission regulation

This report summarises the results of the project EnviSuM - an acronym for "Environmental Impact of Low Emission Shipping: Measurements and Modelling Strategies". In Chapter 1, the authors look at different emission abatement strategies including measurement results from different types of vessels. This section also presents results on the effects of switching fuels, the modelling used to measure ship emissions and compliance monitoring. In Chapter 2, they explore air quality based on emission results. Local air quality was modelled for three urban areas - Gothenburg, Gdansk/Gdynia and St. Petersburg. The effects of shipping emissions on public health and environment are assessed in Chapter 3. In Chapter 4 they discuss the economic consequences of SECA. This includes costs as well as positive effects of SECA, such as inducement to innovate and the enhanced reputation of the Baltic Sea region. The authors conclude in chapter 5 by looking to the future environmental shipping regulations. The report is backed up by a large number of international partner organisations from nine countries, namely the University of Turku (Finland), Chalmers University of Technology (Sweden), Maritime University of Szczecin (Poland), Finnish Meteorological Institute (Finland), Norwegian Meteorological Institute (Norway), University of Gothenburg (Sweden), Tallinn University of Technology (Estonia), City of Gothenburg (Sweden), Voeikov Main Geophysical Observatory (Russia), Maritime Development Center (Denmark), Baltic Marine Consult Ltd. (Germany), Baltic Marine Environment Protection Commission - Helsinki Commission (Finland), Helsinki Commission (Russia), International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (Austria).

Storymap: Baltic Sea Region Shipping Towards Better Air Quality - EnviSuM results

This interactive online narrative presents the role of shipping towards a better air quality in the Baltic Sea Region using animated videos and maps that highlight the results from the Interreg project EnviSuM. Between 2016-2019, the EnviSuM project - an acronym for "Environmental Impact of Low Emission Shipping: Measurements and Modelling Strategies" has assessed the impacts and costs of ship emissions on the scopes of human health, environment and economics. The information in the story map is useful for a wide range of audience: from experts of the field to the people interested in the air emissions and the state of the Baltic Sea.

Decision support tool: SECA investments

This web-based visualised economic decision tool helps maritime fuel producers as well as ship-owners to identify the best short or long-term investment and capital budgeting strategies for the future. Compliance with SECA regulations requires investment decisions with a vast impact, particularly in the case of scrubber installations. The investment tool will help companies estimate costs related to SECA regulations and decide which investments to make in order to comply. The tool was developed during the Interreg project EnviSuM for assessing real options for compliance with maritime sulphur regulations.

Report: Urban air quality measurements in Gothenburg (Sweden), St. Petersburg (Russia) and the Tri City region (Poland)

The Finnish Meteorological Institute compared the measurements of air quality from three large port cities in the Baltic Sea region, namely the Tricity (Gdansk, Sopot and Gdynia) in Poland, Gothenburg in Sweden, and St. Petersburg in Russia. The air quality measurements were made during the years 2016–2018 near the city ports. Measured components for air quality included NOx, SOx, CO, O3, as well as particulate matter PM10 and PM2.5. The comparison helps air pollution experts to assess the effect of the SECA legislation and to evaluate the results of a local modelling study of air quality in the ports of Gdansk and Gdynia – such modelling had been carried out for the first time in Poland in the project EnviSuM.

Policy brief: Sulphur Emission Control Area (SECA) Regulation's Benefits Exceed the Cost. Both are Distributed Unevenly

This policy brief provides policy makers and authorities with recommendations for the development of future environmental regulations, and the shipping sector with guidance to support future investment decisions. It wraps up the results of the transnational cooperation project EnviSuM which analysed the impacts of an environmental regulation on the Baltic Sea environment, economy and people's health from 2016-2018.

Project Stories

Partners

University of Turku

  • Town
    Turku
  • Region
    Varsinais-Suomi
  • Country
    Finland
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
680,130.25
60.451753122.2670522

Chalmers University of Technology

  • Town
    Göteborg
  • Region
    Västra Götalands län
  • Country
    Sweden
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
436,343.00
57.707232611.9670171

Maritime Development Center of Europe/The Transport Innovation Network

  • Town
    Copenhagen
  • Region
    Byen København
  • Country
    Denmark
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
258,678.00
55.686724312.5700724

Norwegian Meteorological Institute

  • Town
    Oslo
  • Region
    Oslo
  • Country
    Norway
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
339,214.00
59.913330110.7389701

Finnish Meteorological Institute

  • Town
    Helsinki
  • Region
    Helsinki-Uusimaa
  • Country
    Finland
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
497,648.00
60.167488124.9427473

Maritime University of Szczecin

  • Town
    Szczecin
  • Region
    Miasto Szczecin
  • Country
    Poland
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
349,375.00
53.430181814.5509623

City of Gothenburg

  • Town
    Gothenburg
  • Region
    Västra Götalands län
  • Country
    Sweden
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
104,454.00
57.707232611.9670171

University of Gothenburg

  • Town
    Gothenburg
  • Region
    Västra Götalands län
  • Country
    Sweden
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
193,270.00
57.707232611.9670171

Baltic Marine Consult Ltd.

  • Town
    Rostock
  • Region
    Rostock, Kreisfreie Stadt
  • Country
    Germany
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
56,634.00
54.092444512.1286127

Nordkalk Corporation

  • Town
    Parainen
  • Region
    Varsinais-Suomi
  • Country
    Finland
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
0.00
60.305448722.2996452

Tallinn University of Technology

  • Town
    Tallinn
  • Region
    Põhja-Eesti
  • Country
    Estonia
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
253,460.00
59.437215524.7453688

Baltic Marine Environment Protection Commission - Helsinki Commission (HELCOM)

  • Town
    Helsinki
  • Region
    Helsinki-Uusimaa
  • Country
    Finland
Approximate total partner budget in EUR
53,333.00
60.167488124.9427473

Videos

Video 1 of 3
Video 2 of 3
Video 3 of 3